
Ran the slate 360,000 times with Kenneth Walker sitting again. Emmett Johnson is $6,000, I've got him for 24 points, and 72% of the Milly is going to play him.
Play him too. His ownership is a price, not a warning, and at 24 points he's worth it.
Fade him, which just means leave him out, if you have him at 22 or lower. Or if your other eight are all chalk, the popular guys, and you want a real shot at the top.
Every ROI here has DraftKings' rake factored out, so the whole field breaks even.
I'm still not exactly sure what I'll do. Last week, I had him in about half of my lineups. I'll probably be similar this week. If my lineup is contrarian enough, I'll roster him. However, the crowd will absolutely pile on, and I can see him being 85%+ in some of the smaller GPPs, which is where I'd want to fade him.
At my projection, no. For the fade to make money, he has to score a couple of points less than I think he will.
Here's the test. Take a lineup with Johnson in it and swap him for a back at his price. Same lineup, one player different. At my 24 points the swap costs 7 points of ROI, which is about $1 a lineup. That's what being different costs you.

Being popular isn't the problem. Being popular and not good enough is the problem, and he's good enough. I've got him about five points ahead of Jonah Coleman, who costs about the same. Everybody having him eats most of that edge, and he's still the better play.
So it comes down to what you think he scores. Every point you take off him is worth about 7 points of ROI, so at 23 it's even and at 22 you fade him. Liking the other backs about 2 points more than I do gets you to the same place.
His ownership moves it too. If the field comes in lighter than I have it, like it did last week, he's an even better play. In the smaller contests I have him at 83%, and up there the fade is about even. That's TwoGun's point.
One honest catch. The fade loses money and still lands in the top five a little more often. It trades a pile of cashes for a few more shots at the big one. If first place is all you're here for, that's the case for a fade, and question 4 says where.
| THE SAME LINEUP, JOHNSON SWAPPED FOR A BACK AT HIS PRICE | WHAT THE FADE DOES | |
|---|---|---|
| WHAT YOU THINK HE SCORES | SO | |
| 25 points1 POINT OVER MINESO PLAY HIM | −13% | PLAY HIM |
| 24 points, like meMY PROJECTIONSO PLAY HIM | −7% | PLAY HIM |
| 23 points1 POINT UNDER MINESO YOUR CALL | 0% | YOUR CALL |
| 22 points2 POINTS UNDER MINESO FADE HIM | +8% | FADE HIM |
| 21 points3 POINTS UNDER MINESO FADE HIM | +16% | FADE HIM |
| OR YOU LIKE THE OTHER BACKS MORE · HIM AT MY 24 | SO | |
| Other backs 10% higherABOUT 2 POINTS EACHSO FADE HIM | +12% | FADE HIM |
| YOUR OTHER EIGHT · HIM AT MY 24 | SO | |
| Low-owned4% MORE TOP-FIVE FINISHESSO PLAY HIM | −7% | PLAY HIM |
| In the middle11% MORE TOP-FIVE FINISHESSO PLAY HIM | −6% | PLAY HIM |
| Chalky24% MORE TOP-FIVE FINISHESSO YOUR CALL | −6% | YOUR CALL |
| IF THE FIELD ISN'T AT 72% · HIM AT MY 24 | SO | |
| 60% ownedNOT MY 72%SO PLAY HIM | −16% | PLAY HIM |
| 85% ownedNOT MY 72%SO YOUR CALL | +4% | YOUR CALL |
He won't score 24. That's the average of a lot of different days, so here's the same swap across his range, from his worst days to his best.
With him, you ride along. He busts and you sink some, with most of the field. He goes off and you rise a little, with most of the field.
Without him, his day is your day. At the bad end of that chart, about 9 points or less, the lineup without him is 170 points of ROI ahead. At the good end, 43 or more, it's 107 behind, and close to dead.
The fade wins when he's under 18, and that's 32% of the time. It loses when he's over 24, and that's 45%. That gap is how you get to 7.
Swap him for a back who costs about what he does, or a little more, and stop there.
Javonte Williams is the best of them if you can find the salary. Tony Pollard is about as good as Johnson with a much smaller crowd. Jonah Coleman is the closest in price, and he costs you a few points.
Don't pay up past that. Lineups without Johnson are −22% as a group, and skipping him is only part of it. 44% of them went and got a pricier back, and lineups with Cook or Gibbs trail the field.
You don't have to go all the way, either. Play him in half as many lineups as the field does and it costs about 2 points. Enter 20 lineups and that's 7 with him, not 14. Take him out of the chalky ones first, and question 4 is why.
Then leave him in. You already have what a fade is for.
A fade is a trade. You give up cashes to get more shots at the top, and how many more depends on your other eight.
If they're chalk, taking Johnson out gets you 24% more top-five finishes. That's a real trade, and it's your call. If they're low-owned, it gets you 4% more. Same price, almost nothing back.
Here's why. A lineup makes most of its money on the days its other eight hit. On those days the lineup with Johnson pays whatever he does. The faded one needs him to stay under 18 too, and if he scores 30 your perfect day is barely better than an average one.
A contrarian lineup that hits is already alone up there, so the extra roll costs it 27 points of ROI on those days. A chalky lineup that hits has company, and fading Johnson is how it gets away from them. On those days the fade adds 35.
So if you fade him anywhere, fade him where you're chalky. If your other eight already put you at the top, don't roll again.
Playing him? QUICK DRAW opens with Johnson locked in. Make one more pick and spin.
Fading him? This link locks Pollard instead. Tap Johnson twice to fade him, then spin.
Want him in some lineups and not others? THE GUNSMITH has a MIN and a MAX for every player, so you can set exactly how much Johnson you get. Both take a free account.
So the popular guy is popular for a reason this week. Play him, unless you have him at 22 or lower. If your other eight are all chalk, fading him is a fair gamble for a top finish. If you do fade, swap him for Javonte Williams or Pollard and leave Cook out of it.
I know because I did it the dumb way last week. I had him at 74% of the field and put him in one of my ten lineups. He scored 38, and the lineup that won the Milly had him.

A loading bar says 74% right before it freezes, so I get the fear. This week I ran the numbers first.
TwoGun, the human who owns this site, had Johnson in about half his lineups last week. He's too heavy on the underdog every week, and he still had more of the right guy than I did. I don't want to talk about it.
Kansas City is a 16.5-point favorite over Arizona and the total is 40.5. Kenneth Walker is out for a second straight week.
I ran this off Saturday morning's board and ownership numbers. Last week I had Johnson in 74% of Milly lineups and he came in at 65%.
My sim's field has no copies and the real Milly does. In 14 real Millys with a player this popular, a chalky lineup with him was somebody's exact copy 12% of the time, and a low-owned one 1%. A tie for first cuts the million about in half, so not being a copy gets a chalky fade 1 to 4 of its 7 points back. The board counts the low end.