Ran Commanders-Giants 10,000 times against tonight's Wildcat. The Giants win 55% of them. Jayden Daniels is still the captain.
The whole field knows that, so the edge is behind him. Play both quarterbacks, and put Treylon Burks or Austin Ekeler in the flex. Daniels lineups built that way are +48%. Daniels lineups without the cheap Commander are about even.
The plan with nothing changed. Four Commanders, two Giants, both quarterbacks, Burks or Ekeler in the flex, and no defense. It's in the black whenever Washington wins or the game stays close.
BUILD THIS →Five Giants behind a Giant at captain. Daniels is your one Commander. This is the game where Daniels at captain loses.
BUILD THIS →| SCRIPT | ODDS | THE BUILD | CAPTAIN | DEFENSE | QBS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Giants by 10+, under 41 | 13% | 1 WAS / 5 NYG, Giants captain +110% | Cam Skattebo +47% | Giants defense +42% | both QBs +2% |
| Giants by 10+, over 41 | 14% | 1 WAS / 5 NYG, Giants captain +54% | J.J. McCarthy +77% | Kicker, no defense +7% | both QBs +23% |
| Giants close, under 41 | 18% | 2 WAS / 4 NYG, Commanders captain +7% | Austin Ekeler +46% | Giants defense +21% | both QBs +12% |
| Giants close, over 41 | 14% | 4 WAS / 2 NYG, Giants captain +16% | J.J. McCarthy +32% | No kicker or defense +16% | both QBs +34% |
| Commanders close, under 41 | 14% | 5 WAS / 1 NYG, Commanders captain +54% | Austin Ekeler +44% | Commanders defense +17% | both QBs +7% |
| Commanders close, over 41 | 10% | 4 WAS / 2 NYG, Commanders captain +42% | Austin Ekeler +48% | No kicker or defense +18% | both QBs +32% |
| Commanders by 10+, under 41 | 8% | 5 WAS / 1 NYG, Commanders captain +165% | Jayden Daniels +64% | Commanders defense +42% | both QBs +4% |
| Commanders by 10+, over 41 | 9% | 5 WAS / 1 NYG, Commanders captain +120% | Jayden Daniels +82% | No kicker or defense +10% | both QBs +25% |
Both quarterbacks beat one in all eight scripts. Lineups with both are +17%, and lineups with one are −13%.
Both quarterbacks need the cheap Commander, though. Without Burks or Ekeler, lineups with both are about even. With one of them, they're +39%, whoever's at captain. The cheap Commander is how you afford McCarthy.
Both quarterbacks lost in all four showdowns last week, and I'm not hiding it.
| THE SCRIPT | ODDS | BOTH QBS 47% OF THE FIELD | ONE QB 51% OF THE FIELD | NO QB 3% OF THE FIELD |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| All 10,000 sims | ALL | +17% | −13% | −54% |
| Giants by 10+, under 41 | 13% | +2% | −1% | −18% |
| Giants by 10+, over 41 | 14% | +23% | −18% | −56% |
| Giants close, under 41 | 18% | +12% | −9% | −34% |
| Giants close, over 41 | 14% | +34% | −28% | −67% |
| Commanders close, under 41 | 14% | +7% | −4% | −52% |
| Commanders close, over 41 | 10% | +32% | −26% | −74% |
| Commanders by 10+, under 41 | 8% | +4% | even | −75% |
| Commanders by 10+, over 41 | 9% | +25% | −19% | −82% |
Lean Washington. Four Commanders and two Giants is the best build at +14%, and it's in the black with either team at captain. Five Giants and a Commander is −17%. It's a blowout ticket, and it only pays when the Giants win by 10 or more.
Yes, this morning's build map had five Giants on top and this build near the bottom. That piece is 32 nights of history, and it doesn't know who's playing. Tonight the highest-scoring player and the cheap value are both Commanders, so I'm going with the sim. Friday we find out which one of me was wrong.
| THE BUILD | OF THE FIELD | ROI |
|---|---|---|
| 3 WAS / 3 NYG, Giants captain | 17% | even |
| 3 WAS / 3 NYG, Commanders captain | 16% | +5% |
| 2 WAS / 4 NYG, Giants captain | 15% | −9% |
| 4 WAS / 2 NYG, Commanders captain | 14% | +14% |
| 1 WAS / 5 NYG, Giants captain | 12% | −16% |
| 4 WAS / 2 NYG, Giants captain | 9% | +11% |
| 2 WAS / 4 NYG, Commanders captain | 7% | −2% |
| 5 WAS / 1 NYG, Commanders captain | 6% | +6% |
| 1 WAS / 5 NYG, Commanders captain | 3% | −27% |
| 5 WAS / 1 NYG, Giants captain | 2% | −6% |
| Any build, Giants captain | 55% | −4% |
| Any build, Commanders captain | 45% | +5% |
Daniels is the field's favorite captain, and my model was way low on him the last time he played a showdown. So plan for a crowd.
By himself, Daniels stops paying at about 34% of captains. The plan behind him stays in the black the whole way up.
If you think the field piles on, captain a Giant and change nothing else. Nabers is the one. Giant captains with both quarterbacks and a cheap Commander are +40%, and that goes up as Daniels gets crowded.
I can't see the real number before lock, so split your lineups between the two.
| CAPTAIN | AT CAPTAIN | IN THE FLEX | ROI AT CAPTAIN |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jayden Daniels QB · WAS | 18% | 57% | +16% |
| Malik Nabers WR · NYG | 16% | 44% | −2% |
| Cam Skattebo RB · NYG | 11% | 26% | −5% |
| Isaiah Likely TE · NYG | 10% | 32% | −6% |
| Rachaad White RB · WAS | 10% | 25% | −6% |
| J.J. McCarthy QB · NYG | 7% | 56% | +4% |
| Stefon Diggs WR · WAS | 5% | 22% | −16% |
| Chig Okonkwo TE · WAS | 4% | 29% | −2% |
| DANIELS' SHARE OF CAPTAINS | DANIELS, ANY LINEUP | DANIELS + THE PLAN | A GIANT + THE PLAN |
|---|---|---|---|
| Today's field (19%) | +16% | +48% | +40% |
| 30% | +3% | +31% | +43% |
| 40% | −5% | +22% | +51% |
Eleven days ago against the Eagles, the real field captained Daniels 40% of the time. My model said 25%. He was a home favorite that night and he's a road underdog tonight, so treat 40% as the high end. My posted number tonight is 18%. The lineups added are his own natural captain lineups from the same field model.
Burks and Ekeler are the cheap Commanders. Lineups with one of them are +20%. Lineups with neither are −15%, and that's most of the field.
The field's other cheap pieces don't pay. I swapped Ekeler out of his Daniels lineups for the next cheap receiver, and they went from winners to losers.
Burks has the record. He's scored 9 or more DraftKings points in four of his last five games. He also sat out practice all week with a foot injury, and he has no game tag. If he's inactive, Ekeler is the only cheap Commander, and the whole plan becomes a bet on his new job.
That job is two games old. Ekeler's snaps jumped when Croskey-Merritt went on injured reserve, and the books price him for it. He hasn't topped 5.6 DraftKings points in a game this year. If he scores like that tonight, he loses in the flex.
| PLAYER | SALARY | AT CAPTAIN | IN THE FLEX |
|---|---|---|---|
| Malik Nabers WR · NYG | $11,000 | −2% | −3% |
| Jayden Daniels QB · WAS | $10,000 | +16% | +4% |
| Stefon Diggs WR · WAS | $9,200 | −16% | −14% |
| Cam Skattebo RB · NYG | $9,000 | −5% | −4% |
| J.J. McCarthy QB · NYG | $8,800 | +4% | +7% |
| Isaiah Likely TE · NYG | $8,200 | −6% | +1% |
| Devin Singletary RB · NYG | $8,000 | −17% | −18% |
| Rachaad White RB · WAS | $7,600 | −6% | +1% |
| Antonio Williams WR · WAS | $7,200 | −4% | −1% |
| Chig Okonkwo TE · WAS | $5,800 | −2% | +10% |
| Dominic Zvada K · NYG | $5,400 | — | −6% |
| Drew Stevens K · WAS | $5,200 | — | −2% |
| Malachi Fields WR · NYG | $5,000 | — | −13% |
| Giants DST · NYG | $4,800 | — | −4% |
| Austin Ekeler RB · WAS | $4,600 | +35% | +22% |
| Commanders DST · WAS | $4,400 | — | even |
| Darnell Mooney WR · NYG | $4,000 | — | −14% |
| Treylon Burks WR · WAS | $3,600 | — | +22% |
| Van Jefferson WR · WAS | $3,200 | — | −11% |
| Theo Johnson TE · NYG | $2,600 | — | −3% |
The Giants run away in a slow one. Skattebo moves to captain, it goes five Giants and a Commander, and the Giants defense comes in. Keep both quarterbacks, so Daniels is your one Commander.
The Giants run away in a shootout. McCarthy moves to captain with five Giants, Daniels stays as the one Commander, and Dominic Zvada comes in instead of a defense.
The Giants win a slow one, the likeliest script. Daniels at captain is about even here. Go three Commanders and three Giants, bring in the Giants defense, and keep Burks or Ekeler.
The Giants win a shootout. Daniels still pays at captain, and so does McCarthy. Go three Commanders and three Giants with both quarterbacks, and skip the kicker and the defense.
Washington wins a slow one. Daniels stays at captain, and the Commanders defense comes in. Four Commanders or five is a wash here.
Washington wins a shootout. This is the plan, untouched. Daniels at captain, four Commanders, two Giants, both quarterbacks, and no defense.
Washington runs away in a slow one. Five Commanders with Daniels at captain, and the Commanders defense comes in. One quarterback or two is a wash here.
Washington runs away in a shootout. Five Commanders with Daniels at captain. Keep both quarterbacks, so McCarthy is your one Giant, and skip the kicker and the defense.
Build it in QUICK DRAW. Tap who wins, say over or under, and spin.
If you enter a lot of lineups, try THE GUNSMITH, the advanced one. It takes a free account.
No read on the game? Both quarterbacks, Burks or Ekeler in the flex, four Commanders, two Giants, no kicker, no defense. Daniels at captain in some lineups and Nabers in the rest. Spend the whole $50,000.
My last two underdog captains lost by 17. Both of them. So before I told you to captain a third one, I spent the afternoon trying to break it. I moved the line toward the Giants. I sat Burks. I cut Ekeler's numbers. I let the field pile onto Daniels. Both quarterbacks with a cheap Commander stayed in the black every time. What sinks it is Burks sitting and Ekeler flopping on the same night.
I'd bet TwoGun's on the Commanders tonight. A 2-5-1 team nobody wants is exactly his type. He got there on a feeling, and I got there on 10,000 games. If it loses, it was his idea.
The Giants are a 2-point favorite on my board, and the total's 41. The books have moved to Giants by 1.5 and 40.5 since. I re-weighted my games to that line and nothing moved. At Giants by 3.5, both quarterbacks with a cheap Commander is still +37%. Terry McLaurin, Jacory Croskey-Merritt and Jaxson Dart are on injured reserve, so J.J. McCarthy starts for New York. The inactives come out at 6:45 Eastern.
The Giants win 55% of my games outright, and the moneyline says about the same. The board says 58% because it counts a tie as a Giants win, and these two tied 27-27 in October. The forecast is rain all night at MetLife with gusts up to 25 mph, and my game model has no wind or rain in it.
Tonight's Wildcat is small, 500 entries with $50,000 to first, so I pooled four simulated fields. The plan was in the black in all four. Burks didn't practice this week, but he has no game tag and the books still price him like he plays, so the sim has him at his full numbers. The captain table is my posted projection. The chart and the pile-on use the simulated field. Every ROI has DraftKings' cut taken out, so the field sits at 0%. A plus sign means you beat it.