
Went through every lineup in 32 big showdowns. 50,846 of them. A third were the same build: four from one team, two from the other, captain from the four. That build is −25%. Blowouts either way crushed it. In the close games it lost by less, close enough to be luck.
It's what you build when you haven't picked a game. Five and one won the blowouts. Three and three won the close games. DraftKings' cut is out of every number, so the whole field sits at 0%, and first place counts. Thursday's game is at the bottom.
It's the easy one to build. You like one team a little more, so you captain their best player and take three of his teammates. Then you add two from the other side, just in case.
That's the problem. A blowout pays the lineup with five. A close game pays three and three. This one is a bet on "I dunno, somebody wins by a medium amount," and a third of the field is making it with you.
It's a habit, too. Every single night, between 29% and 37% of the field built it.
It was above the field on 9 nights out of 32. It had the first-place lineup on 6 of them. A random third of the field would've had the winner on about 16.
Move the captain to the two-man side and it lost less. That version is a lot rarer, though, and the gap could be luck.
| THE BUILD | ALL 32 NIGHTS | FAVORITE BY 14+ · 9 | CLOSE GAME · 18 | UNDERDOG BY 14+ · 5 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| WHAT EACH BUILD RETURNED · THE WHOLE FIELD SITS AT 0% | NIGHTS ABOVE THE FIELD | ||||
| Five favorites, one underdog16% OF THE FIELDNIGHTS ABOVE THE FIELD 12 OF 32 | +50% | +313% | −21% | −96% | 12 OF 32 |
| Three and three32% OF THE FIELDNIGHTS ABOVE THE FIELD 16 OF 32 | +9% | −64% | +28% | +54% | 16 OF 32 |
| Four and two, captain from the two12% OF THE FIELDNIGHTS ABOVE THE FIELD 8 OF 32 | −6% | −62% | +19% | 0% | 8 OF 32 |
| Four and two, captain from the four33% OF THE FIELDNIGHTS ABOVE THE FIELD 9 OF 32 | −25% | −45% | −11% | −35% | 9 OF 32 |
| Five underdogs, one favorite7% OF THE FIELDNIGHTS ABOVE THE FIELD 4 OF 30 | −29% | −100% | −66% | +186% | 4 OF 30 |
| THE MONEY LEFT · EVERY BUILD TOGETHER | NIGHTS ABOVE THE FIELD | ||||
| $300 or less left55% OF THE FIELDNIGHTS ABOVE THE FIELD 18 OF 32 | +8% | −8% | +16% | 0% | 18 OF 32 |
| $400 to $1,000 left31% OF THE FIELDNIGHTS ABOVE THE FIELD 7 OF 32 | −25% | −35% | −29% | +2% | 7 OF 32 |
| $1,100 or more left13% OF THE FIELDNIGHTS ABOVE THE FIELD 10 OF 32 | +27% | +73% | −3% | −6% | 10 OF 32 |
Five from the favorite and one from the underdog came out on top of the board. Don't get excited yet. Take out its three best nights and it's only a little ahead.
The favorite won by 14 or more in 9 of the 32 games. Five and one made all of its money on those nights. In the other 23 it lost big.
So the real question is how often the blowout shows up, and the spread tells you. Over 16 seasons of NFL games, a favorite laying a field goal won by 14 or more 20% of the time. A favorite laying ten did it 39% of the time.
A bigger spread means more blowouts, so five-and-one has a better shot. The field knows it too. It plays more five-and-ones on big spreads, and that shrinks the payout when the blowout comes.
Three and three is +9%. It's the one that doesn't need a blowout. It was ahead in the close games, and ahead when the underdog ran away with it.
It has one bad kind of game. When the favorite runs away with it, three and three is −64%.
So the two builds cover each other. Five and one is for the favorite's blowout. Three and three is for everything else, and at most spreads everything else is most of the games.
Then there's the money you don't spend.
Lineups that left $300 or less came out a little ahead of the field. The red bar is everybody who left four hundred to a thousand. It lost in every build on the board and in both halves of the season, and almost a third of the field does it.
If you've got six hundred left, you're in the zone that lost. It's a loading bar that stops at 98% and calls it done.
The bottom bar's profit comes from one kind of lineup. Two kickers or defenses, and more than a thousand unspent. It's for the game where an offense stalls, and the cheap pieces are the whole point. It's rare and lumpy. It beat the field on only 8 of 29 nights, and three nights made almost all of its money.
Commanders at Giants. The Giants are laying 2. Here's how NFL games at that spread ended.
It's a close game 70% of the time, and a Giants blowout 18% of the time.
Five Giants and a Commander sits at the top of the menu, and it'll miss most nights. Four Giants with a Commander captain and three and three are right behind it, close enough that the order could flip. Split your lineups across the top three, and spend the salary.
Every build gets two bars. The bright one is the lineups that spent nearly all the salary. The dim one is everybody else who made that build. It's all built on the same 32 nights, so trust the order, not the size. I'll print how each build did on Friday. One night can't prove a projection or sink it.
QUICK DRAW SHOWDOWN has a dial for this. Call the game, set THE BUILD? to 5-1 or 3-3, spin, and check what's left before you enter. If you enter a lot of lineups, THE GUNSMITH builds the whole set. Both are free to use.
If you only remember one thing, make it this. Decide what kind of game it is before you build. The 4-2 with the captain from the four is what a lineup looks like when nobody decided.
TwoGun doesn't have this problem. His problem is he's never met an underdog he didn't love, and five underdogs is dead last on Thursday's menu. I haven't told him yet. He'd say the chart's upside down, and then he'd build it anyway.