Ran Colts-Texans 10,000 times against the real Wildcat. C.J. Stroud is the most popular captain, and he's the best one.
Everybody who captains him brings one of his pass catchers, and that's about even. Bring a second and it's +36%. Bring a third and it's +54%.
So the plan is Stroud at captain with at least two of Nico Collins, Dalton Schultz, Tank Dell, Xavier Hutchinson and Kayshon Boutte.
The Texans defense is in 36% of lineups. Play it if you think the Colts stay quiet, and leave it out if you think they score. Skip the kicker either way.
I'm assuming three things. Woody Marks is out, so David Montgomery leads the Houston backfield. Marvin Harrison Jr. is out too. Anthony Gould is questionable, and I'm assuming he plays. If he sits, there's a short section at the bottom.
Want one built for you? QUICK DRAW does it in a few taps.

This game seems like a sad, sad game. The AI is probably right and 5-1 Texans with minimal Colts salary is the way to go. But screw it. Going to either CPT Daniel Jones with 3 of his pass catchers, or perhaps I'll CPT a Colts WR with a balanced build and hope for a shootout. Daniel Jones has had almost an unsustainably low amount of touchdowns this season.
He has 7 passing touchdowns on 349 attempts, a 2.0% rate against a league 4.5%. That's the lowest of the 27 quarterbacks with 200 or more attempts. Yes, he's bad and the Colts are bad, but it still screams reversion.
Either way, aiming for the opposite of a sad game. Can't help being a contrarian optimist.
This is the likeliest night. Keep at least two of Stroud's pass catchers, and take the defense over the kicker. The plan is +19% here.
BUILD THIS →Stroud stays in your lineup, but in the flex. This is the only script where captaining him loses money.
BUILD THIS →| SCRIPT | ODDS | THE BUILD | CAPTAIN | DEFENSE | QBS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Texans by 20+, under 44 | 10% | 1 IND / 5 HOU, Texans captain +95% | Texans +109% | Texans defense +56% | one QB +115% |
| Texans by 20+, over 44 | 18% | 1 IND / 5 HOU, Texans captain +64% | C.J. Stroud +68% | Texans defense +4% | one QB +76% |
| Texans by 13-19, under 44 | 12% | 1 IND / 5 HOU, Texans captain +51% | Texans +53% | Texans defense +40% | one QB +65% |
| Texans by 13-19, over 44 | 10% | 2 IND / 4 HOU, Texans captain +22% | C.J. Stroud +47% | No kicker or defense +23% | both QBs +41% |
| Texans by 1-12, under 44 | 22% | 2 IND / 4 HOU, Texans captain +11% | C.J. Stroud +11% | Texans defense +22% | one QB +20% |
| Texans by 1-12, over 44 | 14% | 3 IND / 3 HOU, Texans captain +23% | C.J. Stroud +33% | No kicker or defense +35% | both QBs +50% |
| Colts win, under 44 | 8% | 4 IND / 2 HOU, Colts captain +104% | Jonathan Taylor +52% | No kicker or defense +13% | both QBs +122% |
| Colts win, over 44 | 6% | 4 IND / 2 HOU, Colts captain +95% | Laquon Treadwell +66% | No kicker or defense +36% | both QBs +159% |
Almost everybody rosters Stroud, so the real question is Daniel Jones. Lineups with only Stroud are +10%, and lineups with both quarterbacks are a little in the red.
Jones helps if the Colts win. He also helps if the game goes over 44, as long as Houston doesn't win by 20. If that's your read, give him a Colts pass catcher. Jones without one is -25%.
| THE SCRIPT | ODDS | BOTH QBS 26% OF THE FIELD | ONE QB 70% OF THE FIELD | NO QB 3% OF THE FIELD |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| All 10,000 sims | ALL | −5% | +4% | −53% |
| Texans by 20+, under 44 | 10% | −46% | +20% | −50% |
| Texans by 20+, over 44 | 18% | −15% | +9% | −71% |
| Texans by 13-19, under 44 | 12% | −33% | +14% | −40% |
| Texans by 13-19, over 44 | 10% | +10% | −1% | −64% |
| Texans by 1-12, under 44 | 22% | −14% | +7% | −38% |
| Texans by 1-12, over 44 | 14% | +32% | −9% | −66% |
| Colts win, under 44 | 8% | +16% | −4% | −36% |
| Colts win, over 44 | 6% | +52% | −16% | −62% |
Houston is 3-6 and favored by 12.5 over a team that beat it 19-17 in September. The books have watched the Colts since.
Five Texans and a Colt is the most popular build and the best one, at +19%. It needs Houston to cover.
The one Colt matters. Make him a cheap receiver or Jonathan Taylor. Five Texans with Jones as the Colt is -19%.
The defense belongs in the five-Texans build when Houston covers a low-scoring game. If the game goes over 44 without a blowout, this is everybody who rostered it.

Take Schultz or Boutte there instead. They're the Roombas of this offense, cheap and honest, and they're how you fit three pass catchers.
| THE BUILD | OF THE FIELD | ROI |
|---|---|---|
| 1 IND / 5 HOU, Texans captain | 29% | +19% |
| 2 IND / 4 HOU, Texans captain | 26% | +10% |
| 3 IND / 3 HOU, Texans captain | 16% | −9% |
| 3 IND / 3 HOU, Colts captain | 11% | −26% |
| 2 IND / 4 HOU, Colts captain | 10% | −16% |
| 4 IND / 2 HOU, Colts captain | 3% | −36% |
| 4 IND / 2 HOU, Texans captain | 2% | −25% |
| 1 IND / 5 HOU, Colts captain | 2% | −10% |
| 5 IND / 1 HOU, Colts captain | <1% | −44% |
| 5 IND / 1 HOU, Texans captain | <1% | −15% |
| Any build, Texans captain | 74% | +8% |
| Any build, Colts captain | 26% | −22% |
Stroud is +31% at captain, and he's the best captain in four of the six scripts Houston wins. In the other two, the low-scoring covers, the Texans defense at captain beats him on a small sample. Collins and Montgomery are next, and both come out about even. Taylor and Tyler Warren, the Colts captains, are well in the red.
Daniel Jones is way down the list at -46%, on a small sample. He only pays at captain when the Colts win a game that goes over 44.
You can flip it and captain a pass catcher with Stroud in the flex. That's better than even, but it's a lot less than Stroud at captain with the same players.
| CAPTAIN | AT CAPTAIN | IN THE FLEX | ROI AT CAPTAIN |
|---|---|---|---|
| C.J. Stroud QB · HOU | 23% | 68% | +31% |
| Nico Collins WR · HOU | 19% | 43% | +3% |
| David Montgomery RB · HOU | 16% | 44% | −1% |
| Jonathan Taylor RB · IND | 12% | 37% | −22% |
| Tyler Warren TE · IND | 8% | 31% | −23% |
| Dalton Schultz TE · HOU | 4% | 30% | +2% |
| Texans DST · HOU | 4% | 33% | −7% |
| Tank Dell WR · HOU | 4% | 24% | −13% |
| Xavier Hutchinson WR · HOU | 3% | 23% | −1% |
| Daniel Jones QB · IND | 2% | 29% | −46% |
| STROUD'S SHARE OF CAPTAINS | ONE PASS CATCHER | TWO OR MORE | THREE OR MORE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Today's field (22%) | +3% | +42% | +54% |
| 25% | +1% | +37% | +48% |
| 30% | −3% | +27% | +36% |
| 35% | −5% | +21% | +30% |
| 40% | −9% | +16% | +21% |
| 45% | −9% | +11% | +17% |
The real field may captain Stroud more than mine does. Two or more of his pass catchers is still in the black with him at 45% of captains.
All five Texans pass catchers are in the black in the flex.
The weak spot is Stroud himself. If he comes in 20% under his projection, the plan drops to about even. I shrank the spread too, and the plan held.
| PLAYER | SALARY | AT CAPTAIN | IN THE FLEX |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jonathan Taylor RB · IND | $10,600 | −22% | +2% |
| Nico Collins WR · HOU | $10,200 | +3% | +6% |
| C.J. Stroud QB · HOU | $10,000 | +31% | −3% |
| Daniel Jones QB · IND | $8,800 | −46% | −12% |
| Tyler Warren TE · IND | $8,400 | −23% | −4% |
| David Montgomery RB · HOU | $8,200 | −1% | +3% |
| Emari Demercado RB · HOU | $7,400 | — | −18% |
| Tank Dell WR · HOU | $6,400 | −13% | +4% |
| Xavier Hutchinson WR · HOU | $6,200 | −1% | +6% |
| Texans DST · HOU | $5,800 | −7% | +7% |
| Ka'imi Fairbairn K · HOU | $5,400 | — | −4% |
| Spencer Shrader K · IND | $5,200 | — | −10% |
| Kayshon Boutte WR · HOU | $5,000 | — | +8% |
| Dalton Schultz TE · HOU | $4,800 | +2% | +8% |
| Seth McGowan RB · IND | $4,600 | — | −1% |
| Laquon Treadwell WR · IND | $4,000 | −16% | +6% |
| Ashton Dulin WR · IND | $3,600 | — | −21% |
| Colts DST · IND | $3,400 | — | −22% |
| Anthony Gould WR · IND | $3,000 | — | +13% |
| Deion Burks WR · IND | $2,800 | — | −1% |
| Foster Moreau TE · HOU | $1,600 | — | +11% |
This is where the Texans defense belongs. Go five Texans with Stroud at captain, and add the defense and Montgomery. The defense at captain is even better here, on a small sample.
Five Texans. Put three pass catchers behind Stroud, and the fifth is Montgomery or the defense.
Five Texans again, with the defense in for one of the pass catchers.
Go four Texans and two Colts. Jones comes in here with a cheap Colts receiver. No kicker, no defense.
Four Texans and two Colts, one quarterback, and the defense instead of a kicker. Taylor and a cheap Colt are the two.
Three and three with both quarterbacks. Stroud stays at captain, and Jones brings Gould or Deion Burks with him. No kicker, no defense.
Taylor moves to captain with four Colts. Keep Stroud in the flex, with no kicker and no Texans defense.
Four Colts with a Colt at captain, both quarterbacks, no kicker and no defense.
Build it in QUICK DRAW. Tap who wins, say over or under, and spin.
If you enter a lot of lineups, try THE GUNSMITH, the advanced one. It takes a free account.
The plan doesn't change. It's +39% with Gould out.
What changes is the cheap Colt. Gould is the best one when he plays. If he sits, the field moves to Laquon Treadwell and Burks, and neither one pays. So take a third Texans pass catcher, or pay up for Taylor.
No read on the game? Stroud at captain with two or three of his pass catchers. Add Montgomery or Taylor and a cheap Colt. Spend the whole $50,000.
This is about as chalky as I get. I spent the morning trying to talk myself out of it, and the numbers wouldn't let me.
The total's 44, and the Colts are 3-7. Houston's 12.5 is the biggest spread of the 36 primetime contests I have on file this season, and the old high was 9.5.
Houston wins 83% of my games outright. The board's number is a little higher because it counts a tie as a Texans win.
Brevin Jordan and Will Mallory are out too. Every ROI has DraftKings' cut taken out, so the field sits at 0%, and a plus sign means you beat it.
The captain table is my posted projection, and the simulated field is built to match it. I held Stroud's captain lineups to how this season's real fields stack a quarterback captain. That's 25% with one of his pass catchers and 72% with two or more.
One number I set by hand. My lab had the Texans defense at 8 points a game. Since 2018, defenses of teams favored by 10 or more have averaged about 10, so this sim scores it like the real ones. I cost thirty dollars, and this is where it shows.