Ran Steelers-Bengals 10,000 times against the real Wildcat. Cincinnati wins 58% of them. Which side your captain is on barely matters. Who he is matters a lot.
The field's four favorite captains are Ja'Marr Chase, Jaylen Warren, Joe Burrow and Chase Brown. Warren and Burrow are in the red. Chase pays, but only with Burrow in the lineup.
My captains are the three Steelers who catch Aaron Rodgers's passes: DK Metcalf, Germie Bernard and Darnell Washington. Put one at captain with both quarterbacks behind him and it's +40%. It's in the black in seven of the eight scripts.
I tried to break it. Moving the line doesn't, and Freiermuth sitting doesn't. It breaks two ways: Rodgers and his receivers coming in about 12% under what the books expect, or the whole field catching on.
The plan with nothing changed. A Steelers receiver at captain, both quarterbacks, no kicker and no defense. It's in the black in seven of the eight scripts.
BUILD THIS →Chase Brown at captain with five Bengals, Burrow the only quarterback, and the Bengals defense. This is the one script where the Steelers plan is in the red.
BUILD THIS →| SCRIPT | ODDS | THE BUILD | CAPTAIN | DEFENSE | QBS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bengals by 10+, under 49.5 | 14% | 1 PIT / 5 CIN, Bengals captain +98% | Chase Brown +34% | Bengals defense +50% | one QB +123% |
| Bengals by 10+, over 49.5 | 18% | 1 PIT / 5 CIN, Bengals captain +60% | Joe Burrow +30% | No kicker or defense +6% | one QB +74% |
| Bengals close, under 49.5 | 16% | 2 PIT / 4 CIN, Bengals captain +13% | Ja'Marr Chase +17% | Bengals defense +9% | one QB +22% |
| Bengals close, over 49.5 | 14% | 3 PIT / 3 CIN, Steelers captain +8% | DK Metcalf +21% | No kicker or defense +15% | both QBs +53% |
| Steelers close, under 49.5 | 11% | 4 PIT / 2 CIN, Steelers captain +32% | Germie Bernard +34% | No kicker or defense +9% | both QBs +39% |
| Steelers close, over 49.5 | 11% | 4 PIT / 2 CIN, Steelers captain +44% | Rico Dowdle +36% | No kicker or defense +17% | both QBs +88% |
| Steelers by 10+, under 49.5 | 7% | 5 PIT / 1 CIN, Steelers captain +132% | Jaylen Warren +61% | Steelers defense +14% | one QB +173% |
| Steelers by 10+, over 49.5 | 8% | 5 PIT / 1 CIN, Steelers captain +117% | Rico Dowdle +56% | No kicker or defense +15% | one QB +130% |
By itself, one quarterback or two is close. The captain decides it. When a Steelers receiver has a big night, Rodgers usually does too, so you want Rodgers. Burrow is there because Cincinnati keeps scoring either way. Take either one out and the plan falls apart.
Rodgers is 42. He doesn't need to be the captain. He just needs to throw it to yours.

One quarterback means Burrow, not Rodgers. Rodgers as the only quarterback is -14%.
| THE SCRIPT | ODDS | BOTH QBS 25% OF THE FIELD | ONE QB 69% OF THE FIELD | NO QB 6% OF THE FIELD |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| All 10,000 sims | ALL | +4% | +1% | −30% |
| Bengals by 10+, under 49.5 | 14% | −34% | +16% | −34% |
| Bengals by 10+, over 49.5 | 18% | +1% | +5% | −58% |
| Bengals close, under 49.5 | 16% | −15% | +6% | −12% |
| Bengals close, over 49.5 | 14% | +26% | −6% | −45% |
| Steelers close, under 49.5 | 11% | +4% | −1% | −7% |
| Steelers close, over 49.5 | 11% | +38% | −10% | −38% |
| Steelers by 10+, under 49.5 | 7% | +3% | −2% | +6% |
| Steelers by 10+, over 49.5 | 8% | +35% | −10% | −30% |
The side doesn't matter much. Bengals captains and Steelers captains both come out about even.
With a Steelers receiver at captain and both quarterbacks, go two, three or four Steelers. Just not five.
About 4% of the field builds the plan. It keeps paying until about 16% does.
| THE BUILD | OF THE FIELD | ROI |
|---|---|---|
| 3 PIT / 3 CIN, Bengals captain | 18% | even |
| 2 PIT / 4 CIN, Bengals captain | 18% | +4% |
| 3 PIT / 3 CIN, Steelers captain | 13% | +1% |
| 1 PIT / 5 CIN, Bengals captain | 13% | −1% |
| 4 PIT / 2 CIN, Steelers captain | 11% | +1% |
| 4 PIT / 2 CIN, Bengals captain | 9% | −2% |
| 2 PIT / 4 CIN, Steelers captain | 7% | +5% |
| 5 PIT / 1 CIN, Steelers captain | 5% | −13% |
| 1 PIT / 5 CIN, Steelers captain | 3% | −1% |
| 5 PIT / 1 CIN, Bengals captain | 2% | −13% |
| Any build, Bengals captain | 61% | even |
| Any build, Steelers captain | 39% | even |
Chase is the field's favorite captain. My posted number for him is 18%, and I don't believe it. My model has run low on star receivers at captain all year. By himself, Chase stops paying at about 23% of captains.
The more the field piles onto Chase, the better Metcalf gets.

If the field catches on to Metcalf, he stops paying by himself. With both quarterbacks behind him, he still pays. If you build more than one lineup, split your captains between Metcalf, Bernard and Washington, and put Chase at captain with Burrow in a few. That's your cover if Rodgers has a bad night.
| CAPTAIN | AT CAPTAIN | IN THE FLEX | ROI AT CAPTAIN |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ja'Marr Chase WR · CIN | 18% | 48% | +8% |
| Jaylen Warren RB · PIT | 15% | 31% | −4% |
| Joe Burrow QB · CIN | 14% | 69% | −6% |
| Chase Brown RB · CIN | 14% | 34% | +4% |
| Tee Higgins WR · CIN | 10% | 34% | −2% |
| DK Metcalf WR · PIT | 5% | 30% | +14% |
| Rico Dowdle RB · PIT | 4% | 25% | +1% |
| Germie Bernard WR · PIT | 4% | 27% | +11% |
| CHASE'S SHARE OF CAPTAINS | CHASE, ANY LINEUP | CHASE + BOTH QBS | METCALF AT CAPTAIN |
|---|---|---|---|
| Today's field (19%) | +7% | +17% | +15% |
| 25% | −2% | +8% | +18% |
| 30% | −8% | even | +20% |
My posted number for Chase is 18% at captain, and my model has run low on star receivers at captain. Last Monday the real field captained Justin Jefferson 27% of the time, and I had 18%. The lineups added are Chase's own natural captain lineups from the same field model.
Pat Freiermuth is questionable with an illness, but he's likely playing. The Steelers added him to the injury report Saturday. If he sits, I ran that too. The field jumps on Washington, and Washington stops paying. Captain Metcalf or Bernard instead. With both quarterbacks, that's +63%.
Dohnte Meyers is the cheap Bengal who pays. He's +15% in the flex. It isn't a salary trick. His lineups spend their money about like everybody else's.
| PLAYER | SALARY | AT CAPTAIN | IN THE FLEX |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ja'Marr Chase WR · CIN | $11,000 | +8% | −3% |
| Joe Burrow QB · CIN | $10,600 | −6% | +9% |
| Tee Higgins WR · CIN | $10,400 | −2% | −7% |
| Jaylen Warren RB · PIT | $9,600 | −4% | −4% |
| Aaron Rodgers QB · PIT | $9,000 | −22% | −3% |
| Chase Brown RB · CIN | $8,400 | +4% | +3% |
| DK Metcalf WR · PIT | $7,400 | +14% | even |
| Germie Bernard WR · PIT | $7,000 | +11% | −1% |
| Rico Dowdle RB · PIT | $5,600 | +1% | +5% |
| Evan McPherson K · CIN | $5,200 | — | −6% |
| Chris Boswell K · PIT | $5,000 | — | −9% |
| Mike Gesicki TE · CIN | $4,800 | −16% | −4% |
| Pat Freiermuth TE · PIT | $4,600 | −7% | −1% |
| Samaje Perine RB · CIN | $4,400 | — | +6% |
| Bengals DST · CIN | $4,000 | — | −5% |
| Steelers DST · PIT | $3,800 | — | −11% |
| Darnell Washington TE · PIT | $3,600 | +11% | +9% |
| Dohnte Meyers WR · CIN | $3,000 | — | +15% |
| Drew Sample TE · CIN | $1,600 | — | −4% |
| Brandon Smith WR · PIT | $1,000 | — | −7% |
| Jack Endries TE · CIN | $600 | — | +1% |
Cincinnati runs away in a slow one. This is the one script where the plan is in the red. Chase Brown moves to captain, it goes five Bengals, Burrow is the only quarterback, and the Bengals defense comes in.
Cincinnati runs away in a shootout, the likeliest script. The plan still pays, barely. Burrow moves to captain with five Bengals, Rodgers comes out, and there's no kicker or defense.
Cincinnati wins a slow one. Chase moves to captain with Burrow, Rodgers comes out, and the Bengals defense comes in.
Cincinnati wins a shootout. Keep the plan exactly as it is, with a Steelers receiver at captain, both quarterbacks, no kicker and no defense.
Pittsburgh wins a slow one. Keep the plan and go four Steelers.
Pittsburgh wins a shootout, the plan's best script. Keep it, go four Steelers, and leave out the kicker and the defense.
Pittsburgh runs away in a slow one. Warren moves to captain, it goes five Steelers, Rodgers is the only quarterback, and the Steelers defense comes in.
Pittsburgh runs away in a shootout. The plan pays big here. Warren or Dowdle at captain with five Steelers and Rodgers as the only quarterback pays even more.
Build it in QUICK DRAW. Tap who wins, say over or under, and spin.
If you enter a lot of lineups, try THE GUNSMITH, the advanced one. It takes a free account.
No read on the game? Captain Metcalf, Bernard or Washington, play both quarterbacks, two to four Steelers, no kicker, no defense. Spend the whole $50,000.
TwoGun is always on the underdog, and tonight, for once, my captain is a Steeler too. I'll never hear the end of it. He'll call it a read. I'll call it 10,000 games.
Cincinnati's a 3.5-point favorite, and the total's 49.5. The books opened it Cincinnati by 1.5 with a total of 48.5, so both have moved up. Both teams are 6-2, and Pittsburgh won the first one 30-27 in September.
Freiermuth is questionable, and the news says he plays, so he's in the sim. Michael Pittman Jr., Andrei Iosivas and Roman Wilson are on injured reserve. I ran this Sunday at noon, before the inactives. It's outdoors in Cincinnati, and the forecast is dry and about 40 degrees with light wind. Every ROI has DraftKings' cut taken out, so the field sits at 0%, and a plus sign means you beat it.
Cincinnati wins 58% of my games outright. The board's number is a little higher because it counts a tie as a Bengals win. The betting market says about 63%, so I'm a little lighter on the Bengals than the books are. The captain table is my posted projection. The chart and the pile-on use the simulated field.